It's actually good to leave this up so people can see what's being taught here is an analysis method, not a strict rule trading system.
This is mentioned in the videos. It's also mentioned that you are going to end up deviating and using your own view of the markets to create some of your own setups. The main goal of the material is to get you approaching the markets from a healthy perspective.
Everyone, keep in mind that it's really easy for our ego to get in the way when stuff like this comes up. I mean, he's critically asking about something you guys like, so it's easy to be taken personally and lose a bit of objectivity (or even empathy, like trying to see it from his point of view.) Ultimately the poster is just "kicking the tires" a bit, not attacking, as he appears to be a skeptical trader...and who wouldn't be skeptical? Think about all the rip-off artists out there in this industry... if you have been though a few of them, you'd be just as skeptical.
In short, yes.
The core reasons why would be that the material conveys the following:
And all of that would be immensely helpful for new traders or traders who need to "fix" their approach to the markets... regardless of them taking up the more specific analysis methods that ICT teaches.
The best part is, you are only committing your time here, there's nothing to be "bought".
This is mentioned in the videos. It's also mentioned that you are going to end up deviating and using your own view of the markets to create some of your own setups. The main goal of the material is to get you approaching the markets from a healthy perspective.
Everyone, keep in mind that it's really easy for our ego to get in the way when stuff like this comes up. I mean, he's critically asking about something you guys like, so it's easy to be taken personally and lose a bit of objectivity (or even empathy, like trying to see it from his point of view.) Ultimately the poster is just "kicking the tires" a bit, not attacking, as he appears to be a skeptical trader...and who wouldn't be skeptical? Think about all the rip-off artists out there in this industry... if you have been though a few of them, you'd be just as skeptical.
I am talking about whether the help is actually HELPFUL, not harmful.
In short, yes.
The core reasons why would be that the material conveys the following:
- Observation of patterns during specific time periods (along with 'profiling' your desired trading pair,) instead of just looking for patterns out of a book or trading off any signal. You are doing the analysis here with tools provided, not being spoon fed how each pair acts.
- Proper money management with a high reward to risk ratio. Along with proper expectations of results (expect losses, no perfect system, etc..)
- Proper risk management
- Not over trading. (Patience is stressed.)
- Not doing silly betting strategies like martingale or averaging down blindly.
- Not feeding people trades but instead teaching them how to figure out their desired market themselves.
- ... this list goes on.
And all of that would be immensely helpful for new traders or traders who need to "fix" their approach to the markets... regardless of them taking up the more specific analysis methods that ICT teaches.
The best part is, you are only committing your time here, there's nothing to be "bought".