ICT Forexmas 2014 / Market Maker Series

FTMO Trader Scouting
the golden gun said:
...traders both claiming..

Lets get the facts in order:
Never claimed anything. I got posted setups and statements. I always let facts speak for me. I proposed that i'm ready and willing to stand behind those.
Then i got challenged about that statement. And i will gladly stand up to show what I claim. That's what credibility is.
Anytime, anywhere, anymarket. Including realtime!
 
Steveu said:
I have been trading for too long to know that trading is an individual skill. You put 10 people and give them a set of rules for entry and exits, you will get 10 sets of results. What's more with ICT's discretionary method?

To know if it works or not, just go back-testing and reveal next candlestick one by one. This function is available on all MT4 platform. So I don't know what proof you want? To proof that he can trade well? So what if he can trade well? Does that means I can trade exactly the same as him? Unless he is a robot and I have a robot expert advisor to trade exactly as him, I feel that these showing of results is meaningless for my trading.

What's more, he is not selling anything and I am not buying anything. So what is there to proof? Proof that it works for him? I want to know if it works for me, not him.

So what if he also can produce wonderful results but that does not means I can trade his style and his method just because he can do it. The best proof is to go on demo and see for yourself what's the results at the end of the month. That is the best proof if you ask me. Anything else is just good to know, nothing to do with me.

Steveu, is Singapore in Maryland by anychance? :ponder:
 
Golden Bull said:
Steveu, is Singapore in Maryland? :ponder:

You mean you don't know how to use google map? Here... https://www.google.com.sg/maps/place/Singapore/@1.3146631,103.8454093,11z/data=!3m1!4b1!4m2!3m1!1s0x31da11238a8b9375:0x887869cf52abf5c4

Yes, you showed your myfxbook, good to know that you can trade very well. So what has that got to do with me?

Will it improve my trading? Does that mean you can teach us to produce the same results? If not, what's the use of showing your results when it does nothing for my trading?

Why not show and teach us how you trade and let us see if it works for us? That would be a positive step forward.

Showing your results only prove that your method works wonderfully for you, that is all.
It doesn't guarantee that my results will be like yours, would it?

It is just a "good to know, but nothing to do with me". Am I right?
 
Steveu said:
...You mean you don't know how to use google map? Here... https://www.google.com.sg/maps/place/Singapore/@1.3146631,103.8454093,11z/data=!3m1!4b1!4m2!3m1!1s0x31da11238a8b9375:0x887869cf52abf5c4
...

I mean suspicious new characters keep popping up.. ;) I'm starting to get paranoid like rod and gg. :p

Steveu said:
Why not show and teach us how you trade and let us see if it works for us? That would be a positive step forward.

Or instead demanding by i don't know what right, scoop around here, and start to learn. The breadcrumbs out there. It's your job to follow them.

Steveu said:
Showing your results only prove that your method works wonderfully for you, that is all.

There are a million ways to trade. And each of them can be right. Its up to you to find what works for you.

Steveu said:
It doesn't guarantee that my results will be like yours, would it?

Why would it? Its an individual sport.


BTW I dont have the will/need/obligation to prove you anything else that im stating ,or to provide guarantees. I'm not selling anything to you or to anyone. When i state/promise something, you can cash that check,worst case scenario i will do my best to stick to my word, what i view as an obligation.
 
Golden Bull said:
There are a million ways to trade. And each of them can be right. Its up to you to find what works for you.

I dont have the will/need/obligation to prove you anything else that im stating ,or to provide guarantees. I'm not selling anything to you or to anyone.

Precisely! So I don't understand why all the hoo-ha here on showing myfxbook instead of just focusing on our own trades.
 
Golden Bull said:
When i state/promise something, you can cash that check,worst case scenario i will do my best to stick to my word, what i view as an obligation.

That would qualify as the reason.
 
I think they're both trying to double-bluff each other, which could potentially lead to a rare and awe-inspiring moment of pure transparency in the otherwise toxic Ego wasteland that is retail trading forums...

But I digress... GO RED TEAM!! :pbnj:
 
Golden Bull said:
i will do my best to stick to my word, what i view as an obligation.

First of all, this is the internet we are talking about.
Secondly, this is you on the internet. You are not him, and he is not you.
At least he shared, what about you? The fact that he is sharing his methods for free is already very generous. More generous than most of us.

He didn't sell anything so, he don't have to share if he don't want to.

To me,
If he share it on time as promised, that's a bonus.
If he share it late, it's a charity.
If he changed his mind and didn't want to share it as promised, he has every right to do so as these are free stuff with no obligation on his side.

So just be thankful that he is still putting out his stuff for free, late or not. Cheers.
 
Steveu said:
This is you. You are not him, and he is not you. At least he shared, what about you? The fact that he is sharing his methods for free is already very generous. More generous than most of us.

He didn't sell anything so, he don't have to share if he don't want to.

If he share it on time as promised, that's a bonus.
If he share it late, it's a charity.
If he changed his mind and didn't want to share it as promised, he has every right to as it is free stuff with no obligation on his side.

So just be glad that he is willing to put his stuff out for free, late or not. Cheers.
thanks ict time is expensive keep your word its all you have
 
Guys let's go back to business pls, all you need to be worried is how to zero-in the entries to lower your Ri:Rw ratio, overall profitability and consistency.
 
garry said:
what ever you say ict ;)

Well, you are trying to act smart only to show how stupid you are.

I wish that I am ICT, but I am not.

I am just more level headed than you to know what is important for my trading, and what is not.

If the moderator has access to my IP address, he will know that I am from Singapore which my profile said that's where I am from.
 
It's a shame that humans are social creatures and naturally want to speak to others about their personal interests.

This FX forum thing doesn't seem productive.
 
I just deleted the last bunch of posts that clearly weren't contributing anything to the topic at hand.

[list type=decimal]
[*]This is an english speaking forum. Nothing against people who speak other languages but we gotta keep our lines of communication consistent.

[*]I don't care if you're paranoid; Accusing a person of being an alias of another poster just because they disagree with you, then going on and on about it, is silly. We, the mods and admin, can find out. If you have a suspicion, just message us or report a post of the offending user and we will investigate.
(Further, Golden Bull, are you seriously pulling that card? There's been only two instances of multiple nicks on this forum since it started and you are technically part of that. :p And no, ICT isn't posting as other people. And yes, Steveu is posting from Singapore.)

[*]Posts are starting to violate Rule #1. I'm going to start giving people a "time out" if they want to be repeat offenders.
[/list]

The action causing me to write out the points above are what leads to this:

outthislife said:
This FX forum thing doesn't seem productive.

And that is exactly the outcome I don't wish for us.
 
Jack said:
I just deleted the last bunch of posts that clearly weren't contributing anything to the topic at hand.
Thanks Jack was really tired of reading all the negativity. We need to be positive and support each other. :thumbsup: :thumbsup: :thumbsup: :thumbsup:
 
Sigh.. about this time we need someone to show up spouting about buying and holding a "basket of currencies". No more stop loss or take profits. Insane profits. Its so easy you can do it on you lunch break on your smart phone.

petrama had it right when he posted that article on daja vu.


I wish ICT would post the rest of the market maker videos before he posts the myfxbooks.... On second thought, I don't care. :D c ya and hope you guys have a profitable week!
 
pipmart said:
Sigh.. about this time we need someone to show up spouting about buying and holding a "basket of currencies". No more stop loss or take profits. Insane profits. Its so easy you can do it on you lunch break on your smart phone.

hhahaha. the good old times :D
 
hey, remember when Fiber was posting 50-70 pip daily ranges last spring, and we were wondering if volatility would ever come back again? lol

now Fiber does 100 pips during asian session. my how the times change. all it takes is a little QE
 
gents,

where does one find the latest market reviews Michael does? he announced one per yesterday evening but can't find it on youtube or his site. Any ideas? thanks
 
FTMO Trader Scouting
Back
Top